Medications:

  • ACEI: angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitor
  • AKI: acute kidney injury
  • ARB: angiotensin receptor blocker
  • ARNI: angiotensin receptor blocker & neprilysin inhibitor
  • BB: beta blocker
  • ESKD: end-stage kidney disease
  • HCTZ: hydrochlorothiazide
  • IKi: funny current channel inhibitor
  • MRA: mineralocorticoid receptor antagonist
  • PCB: placebo
  • sGC stimulator: soluble guanylate cyclase stimulator
  • SGLT2i: sodium glucose co-transporter inhibitor

Outcomes:

  • ACH: all-cause hospitalization
  • ACM: all-cause mortality
  • CVH: cardiovascular hospitalization
  • CVM: cardiovascular mortality
  • HFH: heart failure hospitalization
  • HFM: heart failure mortality
  • RMI: recurrent MI
  • SCD: sudden cardiac death
Excluded population of trial Included population of trial



Outcomes of HFrEF GDMT Trials
with serum creatinine-based renal exclusion criteria

Class Medication Dialysis Cr 3.0-3.5 Cr 2.5-3.0 Cr 2.0-2.5 Cr 1.0-2.0
ACEI Enalapril Excluded CONSENSUS (1987): Enalapril vs PCB: ↓ACM
Excluded: Cr>3.4 mg/dL
Excluded SOLVD (1991): Enalapril vs PCB: ↓ACM, ↓CVM, ↓HFH
Excluded: Cr>2.0 mg/dL
Captopril Excluded SAVE (1992): Captopril vs PCB: ↓ACM, ↓CVM, ↓RMI
Excluded: Cr>2.5 mg/dL
Lisinopril Excluded ATLAS (1999): Lisinopril 35mg vs 2.5-5mg: ↓ACH, ↓HFH
Excluded: Cr>2.5 mg/dL
ARB Valsartan Excluded Val-HeFT (2001): Valsartan vs PCB: ↓HFH
Excluded: Cr>2.5 mg/dL
Candesartan Excluded CHARM Alt (2003): Candesartan vs PCB: ↓CVM, ↓HFH
Excluded: Cr>3.0 mg/dL
Losartan Excluded HEAAL (2009): Losartan 150mg vs 50mg: ↓ACM, ↓HFH
Excluded: Cr>2.5 mg/dL
BB Bisoprolol Excluded CIBIS (1994): Bisoprolol vs PCB: ↓HFH
Excluded: Cr>3.4 mg/dL
Excluded CIBIS II (1999): Bisoprolol vs PCB: ↓ACM, ↓HFH
Excluded: Cr>3.4 mg/dL
Metoprolol MERIT-HF (1999): Metoprolol vs PCB: ↓ACM, ↓CVM, ↓HFH, ↓SCD
No renal exclusion
Carvedilol Excluded COPERNICUS (2009): carvedilol vs PCB: ↓ACM, ↓HFH
Excluded: Cr>2.8 mg/dL
COMET (2003): Carvedilol vs metoprolol low-dose: ↓ACM
No renal exclusion
MRA Enalapril Excluded RALES (1999): Spironolactone vs PCB: ↓ACM, ↓HFM, ↓SCD
Excluded: Cr>2.5 mg/dL
Class Medication Dialysis Cr 3.0-3.5 Cr 2.5-3.0 Cr 2.0-2.5 Cr 1.0-2.0



Outcomes of HFrEF GDMT Trials
with eGFR-based renal exclusion criteria

Class Medication Dialysis eGFR 0-15 eGFR 15-30 eGFR 30-45 eGFR 45-60 eGFR>60
ARNI Sacubitril-valsartan Excluded PARADIGM-HF (2014): sacubitril-valsartan vs enalapril: ↓CVM, ↓ACM, ↓HFH
Excluded: eGFR < 30
MRA Eplerenone Excluded EMPHASIS-HF (2001): Eplerenone vs PCB: ↓CVM, ↓HFH
Excluded: eGFR < 30
SGLT2i dapagliflozin Excluded DAPA-HF (2019): dapagliflozin vs PCB: ↓CVM, ↓ACM, ↓HFH
Excluded: eGFR < 30
empgaliflozin Excluded EMPEROR-Reduced (2020): empagliflozin vs PCB: ↓HFH
Excluded: eGFR < 20
sGC stimulator Vericiguat Excluded VICTORIA (2020): vericiguat vs PCB: ↓CVM, ↓HFH
Excluded: eGFR < 15
Myosin activators omecantiv/mecarbil Excluded GALACTIC-HF (2021): omecantiv/mecarbil vs PCB: ↓CVM, ↓HFH
Excluded: eGFR < 15
Class Medication Dialysis eGFR 0-15 eGFR 15-30 eGFR 30-45 eGFR 45-60 eGFR>60



Outcomes of HFrEF GDMT Trials
that excluded renal patients on miscellaneous criteria

Class Medication "Kidney disease" "No kidney disease"
BB Carvedilol Excluded US Carvedilol (1996): carvedilol vs PCB: ↓CVH, ↓HFM
Excluded: "clinical important renal disease"
Excluded CAPRICORN (2001): carvedilol vs PCB: ↓CVM, ↓ACM
Excluded: "renal impairment"
IKi Ivabradine Excluded SHIFT (2012): ivabradine vs PCB: ↓CVM, ↓HFH
Excluded: "severe renal disease"
Class Medication "Kidney disease" "No kidney disease"

Was this useful? Please consider giving us a tip to offset our costs.
© Jiun-Ruey Hu, MD, MPH & Jiawei Tan, MD (2022)